Cash vs accrual accounting: which one does your business need?

The same month can show a profit on one basis and a loss on the other. Here's what each method actually measures, with examples, and what the tax authorities expect.

Young plant growing out of a pile of coins

Cash and accrual are two ways of answering the question "when did this happen?" Cash accounting records income and expenses when money moves. Accrual accounting records them when they're earned or incurred, whenever the money moves.

Cash basis

On a cash basis, you record income when you receive payment and expenses when you pay them. Your profit for the month is roughly the money that came in minus the money that went out.

Good for: very small businesses, sole proprietors and anyone who wants their books to mirror their bank balance. It's simple, and in the US you generally only pay tax on income you've actually received.

The catch: it can be badly misleading. Bill a big project in December, get paid in January, and December looks like a loss while January looks like a record month. Neither is true.

Accrual basis

On an accrual basis, you record income when you've earned it (usually when you deliver the work or product) and expenses when you've incurred them, even if the cash moves earlier or later. Money you're owed sits in accounts receivable; money you owe sits in accounts payable.

Good for: any business that invoices customers, buys on credit, sells annual subscriptions, holds inventory, or reports to lenders, investors or a board. It's what generally accepted accounting standards (US GAAP, ASPE and IFRS) are built on.

The catch: it takes more work each month (receivables, payables, accruals and deferrals), and your profit no longer equals your cash, so you need a cash flow view alongside it.

The same transactions, both ways

What happenedCash basisAccrual basis
You finish a $10,000 project in December and get paid January 15$10,000 income in January$10,000 income in December; a receivable until January
You pay $12,000 in January for a year of insurance$12,000 expense in January$1,000 expense each month; the rest is a prepaid asset
A customer pays $1,200 up front for a 12-month subscription$1,200 income the day it's paid$100 income each month; the rest is deferred revenue
December wages are paid on January 3Expense in JanuaryExpense in December; a liability until paid

Look at the subscription example. On a cash basis a SaaS company selling annual plans looks wildly profitable in the months it sells them and unprofitable in the months it doesn't. On an accrual basis revenue is smooth and matches the service you actually delivered.

What the IRS allows (US)

  • Many small businesses, including most sole proprietors, partnerships and S corporations, can use the cash method for tax.
  • C corporations, and partnerships with a C corporation partner, generally must use accrual, unless they pass the gross receipts test: average annual gross receipts for the prior three years at or below an inflation-adjusted threshold ($31 million for tax years beginning in 2025).
  • Businesses that pass the test also get simpler options for inventory. Larger businesses with inventory generally need accrual for purchases and sales.
  • Tax shelters must use accrual regardless of size.
  • Changing your tax accounting method usually needs IRS consent, filed on Form 3115.

What the CRA expects (Canada)

  • The CRA generally requires business and professional income to be reported on the accrual basis.
  • Farmers and fishers can choose the cash method.
  • Some professionals have special rules for work in progress, so check with your accountant if you bill for professional services.
  • GST/HST is generally reported based on when you invoice or are paid, whichever comes first, not simply when cash arrives. That catches out a lot of cash-basis bookkeepers.
Your books and your tax return can differ. Many businesses keep accrual books for management and lenders, and let their CPA handle the tax method. QuickBooks Online and Xero can both run most reports on either basis.

Signs it's time to switch to accrual

  • You invoice customers and wait 30 days or more to be paid
  • You sell annual plans, memberships, season registrations or prepaid packages
  • You carry inventory
  • A bank, investor, buyer or board asks for financial statements
  • Your monthly profit swings wildly in ways that don't match how busy you were

Switching means setting up opening receivables, payables, prepaids and deferred revenue, then closing each month on the new basis. It's a common part of the accounting and reporting work we do, and it's much easier when the books are already clean and current.

This guide is general information for businesses in the US and Canada, not tax or legal advice. Rules change, so confirm anything specific to your situation with your CPA or tax advisor.